In the overnight hours, early Saturday morning, the Supreme Court temporarily halted the deportation of a group of Venezuelan gangbangers by the Trump administration using the Alien Enemies Act.
Justice Thomas and Alito both dissented.
Here’s the order that came about 1:00am:
Here’s more via The Hill:
The Supreme Court early Saturday halted the administration’s ability to use the Alien Enemies Act to swiftly deport migrants to El Salvador who are being detained in portions of Texas, for now.
The emergency order temporarily blocks the deportations until the high court resolves the American Civil Liberties Union’s (ACLU) emergency appeal, which was filed hours earlier over concerns that more deportation flights were imminent.
Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, two of the court’s leading conservatives, dissented.
The ACLU simultaneously asked several courts to immediately intervene Friday, warning that the Venezuelan migrants could otherwise be given life sentences in a notorious Salvadoran megaprison without the opportunity for judicial review.
“The Government is directed not to remove any member of the putative class of detainees from the United States until further order of this Court,” the Supreme Court’s order reads.
The class extends to any migrant detained in the Northern District of Texas who is being removed under the 18th century Alien Enemies Act. It does not apply elsewhere, though judges overseeing separate cases have temporarily blocked deportations for those detained in the Southern District of New York and the Southern District of Texas.
Deputy Assistant Attorney General Drew Ensign pushed back at a lower court hearing, however, saying no deportation flights were scheduled for Friday or Saturday.
“But I have also been told to say that they reserve the right to remove people tomorrow,” Ensign cautioned.
The ACLU took an aggressive approach once it became aware of the deportations, giving U.S. District Judge James Hendrix, a Trump appointee in Texas who is overseeing the case, just minutes to act before the civil rights group began appealing Friday afternoon.
Criticizing that short window, a three-judge 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel unanimously denied the group’s appeal as premature early Saturday.
“We do not doubt the diligence and ability of the respected district judge in this case to act expeditiously when circumstances warrant,” the 5th Circuit’s unsigned ruling reads. “Petitioners insist that they tried to proceed before the district court in the first instance, and that the district court simply ‘refus[ed]’ to act. But the district court’s order today indicates that Petitioners gave the court only 42 minutes to act.”
The 5th Circuit panel comprised of Trump appointees Judge James Ho and Judge Cory Wilson, and Judge Irma Carillo Ramirez, an appointee of former President Biden.
Separately, the ACLU had unsuccessfully asked U.S. District Judge James Boasberg, an appointee of former President Obama who serves in the nation’s capital, to block the deportations. Boasberg oversees the ACLU’s challenge to the original wave of March 15 deportations when Trump first invoked the Alien Enemies Act.
At the end of an emergency hearing Friday evening, Boasberg ruled he had no jurisdiction following the Supreme Court’s ruling last week that the migrants must challenge their removals where they are physically detained.
The judge also found probable cause Wednesday to hold the Trump administration in criminal contempt for willfully disobeying his order to immediately halt deportations and turn around any airborne planes. An appeals court on Friday temporarily blocked any contempt proceedings.
That’s a lot to digest. In short, the ACLU tried to do an end run around the district court judge, after giving him only 42 minutes to halt the deportations, and went straight to the Fifth Circuit. They felt the appeal was premature and refused to take any action. However the Supreme Court did take action to halt the deportations, for now, and if I had to guess, Alito and Thomas probably feel the same way the Fifth Circuit did.