THE AMERICA ONE NEWS
Jun 24, 2025  |  
0
 | Remer,MN
Sponsor:  QWIKET 
Sponsor:  QWIKET 
Sponsor:  QWIKET: Elevate your fantasy game! Interactive Sports Knowledge.
Sponsor:  QWIKET: Elevate your fantasy game! Interactive Sports Knowledge and Reasoning Support for Fantasy Sports and Betting Enthusiasts.
back  
topic
National Review
National Review
30 Nov 2023
Michael Brendan Dougherty


NextImg:The Corner: R.I.P. Shane McGowan

In a recent statement, The Pogues said that the band’s lead singer and songwriter, Shane MacGowan, has died at age 65, surrounded by family and having received the last rites.

Born in Kent, England, MacGowan’s family hailed from County Tipperary in Ireland. He would go on to found and lead The Pogues, a Celtic punk band. His songwriting was as precise as his self-presentation was shambolic. Consider the reeling, hilarious, joyously vulgar tribute to a race horse named “Bottle of Smoke“:

Thanks and praises, thanks to JesusI bet on the bottle of smokeI went to hell and to the racesTo bet on the bottle of smoke
The day being clear, the sky being brightHe came up on the left like a streak of lightLike a drunken f*** on a Saturday nightUp came the bottle of smoke
20 f***ing five to oneMe gambling days are doneI bet on a horse called the “Bottle of smoke”And my horse won
Stewards inquiries, swift and fieryI had the bottle of smokeInquisitions and suppositionsI had the bottle of smoke
F*** the stewards a trip to LourdesMight give the old f***ers the power of sightScreaming springers and stoppers and call out coppersBut the money still gleams in my hand like a light

Some years ago, I wrote about the sentimental genius of “Fairytale of New York,” one of the few Christmas songs written after the 1960s that will live on for another century or more.

In his compilation of essays, Feckers: 50 People Who Fecked Up Ireland, John Waters wrote about the surprising way that MacGowan was able, as an Irish-Londoner, to take Irish music in hand with a joy, pride, and inventiveness that seemed impossible for the native Irish who either revered their musical tradition too much to experiment with it, or disdained it as a kind of false Paddyism:

For here was a music that simultaneously expressed both our attachment to a slightly false version of ourselves and an ironic repugnance of it. As though insisting on some undefined ethic of rigour and clarity, it reached into the heart of the music, wrenched the sentimentalist heart out of it and cast it away. It was at once a celebration and a refusal, a kick and a kiss. It was a soundtrack for the neurosis born of the post-independence failure of Irish culture to find a way of jump-starting itself — but also, for the same reasons, a living, leaping, soaring blurt of the spirit that had become suppressed. It was a deconstruction of something recognizable as having been put together in slightly the wrong way — the clue that much more than this was fundamentally wrong. The Pogues offered a rejection, but only of the superficial presentation, the sugar coating. The deeper qualities were subjected to a firm and passionate embrace, pulled together and kicked onstage. The music conveyed an unmistakable sense of nostalgia, but also a rage that seemed to announce itself as deriving from the overall tragedy of Irish history. There was mockery, too, but of a gentle kind that seemed to comprehend the extent of the pathos to be dealt with. It had both pride and the awareness of a received loathing. It celebrated and mocked at the same time. It did not choose between allegiance and disdain, but crammed them both into the same mix.

The song that always floors me though is “Thousands are Sailing,” a song about the Irish who were emigrating from Ireland to New York in the depths of the economic downturn and Troubles of the 1980s. It begins with an encounter with a famine emigrant ghost from the past:

The island, it is silent nowBut the ghosts still haunt the wavesAnd the torch lights up a famished manWho fortune could not save
Did you work upon the railroad?Did you rid the streets of crime?Were your dollars from the White House?Were they from the Five-and-Dime?
Did the old songs taunt or cheer you?And did they still make you cry?Did you count the months and yearsOr did your teardrops quickly dry?

Here, precisely is the genius of MacGowan. He has invoked all the potential clichés and romance of Irish immigration to America. The ghost answers with the grim reality, dead before arrival:

“Ah, no”, says he, “it was not to beOn a coffin ship I came hereAnd I never even got so farThat they could change my name”

The song narrates the lives of men and women who celebrate the “land that make us refugees” in the streets, and revel in all the possibilities and opportunities that New York might offer them, though many of them never realize it themselves:

Postcards we’re mailing of sky-blue skies and oceans
From rooms the daylight never sees
And lights don’t glow on Christmas trees

But we dance to the music and we dance

From my childhood, there are haunting memories of precisely these men and women hovering above me as we moved from bars to a tight apartments in Queens. Men laughing broadly as they retold horrors about gunfire in the Divis Flats. Women, thinking their children had gone to sleep on the pullout, moaning in hopes that they earn enough money that year visit their mammy. And my own mother, listening to them, who could throw more light on these memories, is now gone more than a decade. I meet them all as ghosts in MacGowan’s songs. R.I.P.