THE AMERICA ONE NEWS
May 31, 2025  |  
0
 | Remer,MN
Sponsor:  QWIKET 
Sponsor:  QWIKET 
Sponsor:  QWIKET: Elevate your fantasy game! Interactive Sports Knowledge.
Sponsor:  QWIKET: Elevate your fantasy game! Interactive Sports Knowledge and Reasoning Support for Fantasy Sports and Betting Enthusiasts.
back  
topic
America One News
Retail Insider
28 Jun 2023
Sylvain Charlebois


NextImg:International Retailers Such as Aldi and Lidl Might Not Enter Canada Because of Local "Price-Fixing and Manipulative" Grocers [Op-Ed]

International Retailers Such as Aldi and Lidl Might Not Enter Canada Because of Local “Price-Fixing and Manipulative” Grocers [Op-Ed]

Date:

“According to the Competition Bureau, Canadian grocery shoppers require additional foreign players like Aldi and Lidl to lower food prices in Canada. But one may wonder why a foreign grocer would choose to invest in Canada, given the presence of an exclusive club of price-fixing executives who have manipulated market conditions for years with impunity.”

The Competition Bureau’s call for increased competition in the Canadian grocery sector is stating the obvious. Canada is home to numerous oligopolies that dominate various industries, with only a few companies holding significant market share. In the grocery sector specifically, five major players control nearly 80 percent of the food retail market. While some oligopolies function more effectively than others, their success depends on the companies behaving ethically, which is precisely the issue plaguing the grocery sector in Canada.

Loblaw, Empire/Sobeys, and Metro hold the reins as dominant grocers in the market. Although these companies are well-managed, the Competition Bureau’s recent report highlights some of their practices aimed at maintaining market dominance. One notable aspect of the report is the endorsement of the Grocer Code of Conduct. While the Code itself is not directly related to the Bureau, it significantly contributes to enhancing competition. By providing a platform to address supply chain disputes, the Code serves as a necessary disciplinary measure against grocers who abuse their market power, granting food manufacturers more influence. Consequently, independent grocers gain access to a wider range of products and increased protection. Ultimately, the Code offers consumers more choices and potentially more stable retail prices, making it a positive development worth applauding.

Additionally, the report emphasizes the need for all levels of government to participate in making the food market in Canada more competitive. This point cannot be stressed enough. Many consumers are unaware of how territorial grocers can be when expanding into small cities and towns across the country. They may acquire plots of land to prevent competitors from opening stores nearby, and shopping mall leases may include terms that restrict the operation of other food retail outlets. While seemingly insignificant to city councils and mall managers, these measures can have a considerable impact on market prices. In contrast to the United States, where the intricacies of mergers, acquisitions, and their effects on consumers are closely scrutinized, Canada lacks a similar level of attention to such matters. This discrepancy needs to be addressed.

The report suggests that Canada should tackle interprovincial barriers to attract external players like Aldi and Lidl, two German-based grocers that have already been operating in the United States for several years. The ways, means, and locations for selling food products vary significantly between provinces, and labour laws also differ. When Walmart entered the Canadian market in 1994, it faced challenges and made mistakes along the way. Walmart Canada now has over 400 stores across the country, but it took years. On the other hand, Target’s entrance into the Canadian market in 2014 failed miserably due to the intricacies of our market, and this experience has served as a lesson for many companies worldwide, including Aldi and Lidl.

Entering the United States is considerably easier, even for Canadian businesses. This fact is exemplified by Canada’s own T&T, operated by Loblaw, which is currently expanding into the American market where competition is even more intense. Greater opportunities, less bureaucracy, and a more flexible fiscal regime contribute to this favorable environment. However, the most significant aspect is America’s clear understanding of competition as a concept, with an unwavering commitment to eliminating monopolies and oligopolies. Americans view competition as an essential aspect of the market and are vehemently opposed to excessive consolidation, philosophically.

In Canada, too much competition can indeed become an issue. Our love-hate relationship with the concept has resulted in the establishment of crown corporations and “legal cartels” in various sectors, including dairy, eggs, poultry, and maple syrup, to name a few. We have grown accustomed to these marketing mechanisms, at least until prices become a problem for consumers. At that point, we expect the government to intervene. This conflicting attitude towards competition poses one of the greatest challenges for the Competition Bureau.

The desire for increased competition and the attraction of more players to the grocery sector necessitate that the Competition Bureau takes effective action. The food industry is currently grappling with a genuine problem of a price-fixing culture, which erodes consumer trust. We are now discovering that the bread scandal is about more than just bread. These revelations are making Canada a less appealing place to invest. Executives at Aldi and Lidl can read the headlines. Instead of granting immunity to executives or waiting for companies to confess, it is time to investigate and pursue legal action against companies that choose to violate the law. In the United States, engaging in collusion can result in imprisonment. It’s that simple.

Sylvain Charlebois
Sylvain Charlebois
Dr. Sylvain Charlebois is Senior Director of the Agri-Foods Analytics Lab at Dalhousie University in Halifax. Also at Dalhousie, he is Professor in food distribution and policy in the Faculty of Agriculture. His current research interest lies in the broad area of food distribution, security and safety, and has published four books and many peer-reviewed journal articles in several publications. His research has been featured in a number of newspapers, including The Economist, the New York Times, the Boston Globe, the Wall Street Journal, Foreign Affairs, the Globe & Mail, the National Post and the Toronto Star.

2 COMMENTS

  1. Aldi can expand to Canada and be a major success, no matter what major retailer executives say Hey keep the competition south of the border. Aldi is well suited, to make a success here in Canada. We have watched the past 5 years in south west Florida who their foot traffic has expanded. We love to got there on a regular basis. If there was not room for competition in Canada, gas store convenience ones, would never have made it. Ha, they just keep growing, expanding and some buying up other chains. Go Aldi Go!

  2. I was in a Lidl store in the Virginia suburbs of Washington DC recently and in addition to not finding it all that cheap, I was surprised at the very limited range of products it offered compared to No Frills or Food Basics. There was also a seriously odd aisle with a mixed bag of housewares, gardening supplies and other non-food sundries. Nice looking store, very much like the one pictured above, but my feeling was Lidl would not take much market share from Canada’s existing discount grocery chains.

LEAVE A REPLY Cancel reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

RECENT RETAIL INSIDER VIDEOS

Advertisment

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

Related articles

Zellers to Open 21 Pop-ups in Hudson’s Bay Stores in Canada, Aiming to Shape Future Retail Strategy

The Zellers concept is being tested in smaller markets following a spring relaunch of the brand within Hudson's Bay stores.

New Brands Transforming Toronto’s Yorkville Avenue into Youthful High-End Retail Destination [Feature]

Kith, John Elliott, and other brands are expected to drive considerably more foot traffic into the Bloor-Yorkville area coming this fall. 

Tech-Driven Entertainment Experience ‘Illuminarium’ to Open as Key Tenant at Toronto’s Distillery District [Interview]

The unique highly experiential attraction, only the third in the world, will act as a draw to bring in more visitors to the rapidly transforming Distillery District.

Push to Self Checkout Creates Negative Customer Experience in Loblaw Stores [Podcast]

Craig and Lee discuss frustrations with self checkouts, focusing on their experiences at Loblaws and Shoppers Drug Mart.

Walmart Canada CEO Gonzalo Gebara Discusses Retailer’s Plans for Continued Growth and Omni-Channel Expansion [Feature Exclusive Interview]

The retail behemoth is investing heavily in its Canadian operations to continue to grow its market share according to Gebara, who discusses the company's operations and future in this country.

Canadian Cities Seeing Empty Downtown Spaces and Food Deserts Amid Reduced Foot Traffic [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois discusses the future of grocery and foodservice in Canada's urban cores as foot traffic and spending is down following the pandemic.

Nespresso Expands Presence in Ottawa with New ‘Neighbourhood Concept’ Streetfront Store at Lansdowne Live Development [Interview]

The storefront replaces a location at CF Rideau Centre which recently shuttered, and Nespresso says it has plans to roll out more retail locations including in the suburbs.

Erin Mills Town Centre in Mississauga Adding New Retailers with Eye on Future Residential Use [Interviews]

The shopping centre's landlord continues to update the tenant mix as it also strategizes future opportunities to intensify the 84 acre site with residential and other uses.

Interviews: Interactive Multi-Sensory Art Exhibit ‘Arcadia Earth’ to Open Permanent Location at ‘The Well’ in Toronto

The unique 17,000 square foot activation will act as an attraction to drive traffic to the new mixed-use complex that houses a substantial amount of retail space.

Retailers at the Top in New Study on Canada’s Most Trusted Brands [Interview]

The study highlights why some consumers trust some retailers and not others, according to the dean of the Gustavson School of Business in an interview.

Development Surge Along Vancouver’s Kingsway Could Spark Retail Renewal [Feature]

One of the longest and busiest thoroughfares in the Lower Mainland is seeing significant updates by developers, with new retail to follow.

Exploring the State of Canadian Retail: Consumer Trends and Challenges [Podcast]

Craig and Lee dive into the current state of the Canadian retail industry, discussing recent consumer trends and challenges.