Earline Klapka, a former Democrat voter who was waiting in line with her grandchildren, said she had no idea what Mr Shapiro had done for Pennsylvania.
She broke with the party when Barack Obama was elected president, claiming he had been weak on the economy and immigration. “We knew then – no more Democrats,” she said.
Even if Mr Shapiro can peel away some of the Trump base, then he could cause problems in other states. As a vocal supporter of Israel, he could isolate voters in Michigan, a swing state with a high concentration of Muslim and Arab Americans, and young voters.
Mr Urban believes it is futile for Ms Harris to chase blue collar voters and that her only shot in Pennsylvania is to run up her margins in urban areas like southern Philadelphia.
“Trump still is in the 60-40 camp of winning the state, as it stands today. You add Shapiro to that, it goes 55-45. It’s closer, maybe even closer than that – but Trump still wins,” he said.
“Mark Kelly – he’s a legit navy fighter pilot, combat-decorated, gun-owning, tough on the border. He scares me the most.”
The Arizona senator, a Gulf War veteran and former astronaut, has pushed the Biden administration to take a tougher stance on illegal migration. Many believe he could deflect attacks on Ms Harris as a failed “border tsar” who has overseen record crossings.
He is popular with voters – including the crucial Latino demographic – in Arizona, which Mr Biden narrowly won in 2020. Paul Wade, a teacher in the bellwether Maricopa County, praised Mr Kelly’s “integrity” and “obvious competence” and said he wanted him to join Ms Harris’ ticket.
“Kelly brings a message balance between a guy who shores up Kamala’s greatest weakness, which is the immigration issue, with a higher level of appeal to Latinos than Biden and Harris,” Mike Madrid, a political consultant who has previously campaigned against Trump in Arizona, said.
However, Mr Kelly is vulnerable in other ways, with his links to Chinese investors and lucrative corporate speaking jobs being scrutinised in recent days.
He has said he will be in Arizona next week, when the vice-presidential nominee is scheduled to campaign in Philadelphia.