THE AMERICA ONE NEWS
Jun 1, 2025  |  
0
 | Remer,MN
Sponsor:  QWIKET 
Sponsor:  QWIKET 
Sponsor:  QWIKET: Elevate your fantasy game! Interactive Sports Knowledge.
Sponsor:  QWIKET: Elevate your fantasy game! Interactive Sports Knowledge and Reasoning Support for Fantasy Sports and Betting Enthusiasts.
back  
topic
The Telegraph
The Telegraph
25 Mar 2024
Nataliya Vasilyeva


Benjamin Netanyahu faces cabinet rebellion over Israeli military service exemption

Benjamin Netanyahu is facing the gravest threat to his government since October 7 amid a cabinet rebellion over the exemption of ultra-orthodox Jews from military service.

Ministers are due to meet on Monday evening to discuss the final draft of a bill that continues to allow the so-called Haredim to avoid being called up to the IDF.

Israel has permitted the Haredim to focus on their religious studies rather than perform national service since the foundation of the state in 1948, but there is growing criticism of their protected status as tens of thousands of citizens are called up to fight the war in Gaza.

On Sunday, Yoav Gallant, Israel’s defence minister, said he would not back a bill that enshrines the Haredim’s right to avoid service. He urged hardline religious coalition members to be more “flexible” on the issue.

“I will not be party to any proposal that is not agreed upon by all coalition factions – under my leadership, the security system will not submit it for legislation,” Yaov Gallant said before leaving for the United States on his first foreign trip since the start of the conflict last year.

Benny Gantz, Israel’s most popular politician and a member of the war cabinet, also threatened to leave the government if the bill is passed. He has long called for a new conscription law that would see all members of Israeli society, including Haredim and Arab citizens, compelled to serve in either military or civic fields.

Mr Netanyahu’s coalition government has a slim majority and could collapse if enough members quit over the bill.

The increasingly influential Haredi community staunchly opposes conscription, insisting that military service endangers their way of life built on studying the Torah.

Ultra-orthodox civilian members of a first-response tactical team take part in an exercise
Ultra-orthodox civilian members of a first-response tactical team take part in an exercise Credit: MENAHEM KAHANA/AFP

In a last-moment attempt to save the bill, Mr Netanyahu, who relies on Haredi parties to shore up his government, on Monday agreed to remove a clause raising the exemption age from 26 to 35, Israeli media reported.

This would have made it more bureaucratically complicated for Haredim to avoid service, as they are required to get one-year deferrals from service every year until they age out at 26.

The move came after Israel’s attorney general over the weekend warned that the current exemptions framework has been repeatedly ruled illegal by Israeli courts.

A new proposal that would also likely to set enlistment goals for Haredim is to be offered to the cabinet later on Tuesday, according to the Yedioth Ahronoth newspaper.

Despite pressure from liberal members of his cabinet, Mr Netanyahu’s bill does not include draft quotas for ultra-orthodox men or criminal liability for draft dodgers.

If approved by the cabinet, it will likely take a couple of more months before the Knesset considers it and, possibly, votes it into law.

On Monday, Israeli politicians from across the political spectrum, barring the ultra-orthodox, blasted Mr Netanyahu’s exemption U-turn as a “moral disgrace” and “draft-dodging” amidst the country’s most devastating war in a generation.

A group bringing together special ops veterans on Sunday issued a statement, warning that if the “scandalous draft-dodgers’ bill” is passed, it “will be a final breach of contract between the state and us”.

Brothers in Arms, a protest group composed of IDF reservists, slammed the bill as undermining Israel as a secular state.

“If the government passes the law, every Zionist Israeli who worries for the future of the homeland, must take to the streets,” the group said in a statement, accusing the prime minister of trading secular values for his political survival.

A member of parliament from what is now Israel’s most popular political party condemned Mr Netanyahu’s bill as a slap in the face for Israeli soldiers risking their lives in Gaza.

Matan Kahana of the National Unity Party told the Kan radio station on Monday: “How is it even possible to put forward a bill that is so divorced from reality and to keep sending soldiers into battle?” He also called the proposal a “moral disgrace”.

Prominent Haredim leaders have rebelled against the idea of enlisting members of their community, with one prominent rabbi suggesting the ultra-orthodox men would rather flee Israel than join the army.