The headlines are already rolling in: “Experts dismiss claims linking Tylenol to autism.” Before anyone’s even had a chance to breathe, the medical establishment is circling the wagons. Why? Because nothing terrifies the so-called “experts” more than someone daring to question their orthodoxy.

In the White House press conference held on September 22, 2025, President Donald Trump asserted that the Food and Drug Administration will issue a warning to doctors that acetaminophen, the ingredient in Tylenol, “can be associated with a very increased risk of autism” when used during pregnancy. He advised pregnant women to avoid Tylenol unless it is medically necessary, saying, “Don’t take Tylenol,” and went further: “There’s no downside. Don’t take it,” urging caution also for children.

READ MORE: MAHA Level Achieved: Trump Makes a Huge Announcement on His Plan to Combat and Treat Autism

Let’s be clear: I’m not here to prove or disprove whether prenatal Tylenol use could contribute to autism. That’s not the point. The point is the reflexive, knee-jerk hostility toward even asking the question. When did “science” become less about discovery and more about protecting reputations?

Medical history is one long cautionary tale of “settled science” gone wrong. Doctors once told women that smoking during pregnancy was safe. They prescribed thalidomide to expectant mothers, only to discover later that it caused birth defects. They handed out opioids like candy, assured the public they weren’t addictive, and left the country with a drug crisis that still kills tens of thousands a year. These weren’t fringe quacks; they were the mainstream voices of “medical authority.”

So when parents and researchers today raise legitimate concerns about Tylenol, what do we see? The same old pattern: rapid-fire media pieces declaring the matter closed, experts scoffing at the very idea, and the establishment treating any skeptic as reckless, conspiratorial, or anti-science.

But here’s the truth: Dismissing questions isn’t science. It’s PR. And it reeks of insecurity.

Real science says: “That’s interesting, let’s dig deeper.” Establishment “science” today says: “Shut up. Don’t ask. Don’t think.” Which one inspires trust?

The arrogance is the problem. Too many in medicine and public health are more worried about being right than being honest. They confuse protecting their brand with protecting people. And when you put brand management over patient safety, you stop being scientists and start being bureaucrats.

If future studies confirm there is no link between Tylenol and autism, great. Parents deserve to know that, too. But why the sheer panic at the possibility? Why the immediate press campaigns? Why the defensive posturing designed to shut the conversation down before it starts?

Because this isn’t about the science, it’s about control. Control over the narrative, control over what questions you’re allowed to ask, and control over who gets to decide what’s “safe.”

And here’s the irony: By smothering the debate, the experts make people trust them less, not more. Parents aren’t blind. They see the pattern. They hear the scolding. And they remember how many times they’ve been told “everything is fine” right before disaster proved otherwise.

The truth is simple: Parents have every right to demand answers. They aren’t ignorant. They aren’t conspiracy theorists. They are the ones with the most skin in the game, their children’s lives.

If the medical elite truly cared about protecting people instead of protecting their pride, they would encourage research, not ridicule it. They would welcome scrutiny, not fear it. Because science that can’t handle questions isn’t science at all, it’s dogma.

And here’s the part no one wants to admit: The hostility isn’t just about the white coats and their egos. It’s about money. Billions of dollars ride on keeping Tylenol, and countless other drugs, untouchable. Big Pharma doesn’t fund studies that might tank their profit margins, and their friends in the media and government are only too happy to shout down anyone who does.

Science should never be afraid of questions. Only frauds are. And when “medical experts” act more like marketing departments for drug companies than truth-seekers, you don’t have science, you have sales.

Editor’s Note: Do you enjoy RedState’s conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.

Join RedState VIP and use the promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your VIP membership!