By Bianca Gracia
When future economic historians examine the fates of U.S. Steel and America’s industrial base, they will find a perfect case study in two competing styles of leadership: Joe Biden’s passive, protectionist failure and Donald Trump’s confrontational, results-driven success.
Consider the facts. In December 2023, Nippon Steel offered to acquire U.S. Steel for $14.9 billion. It was a bold bid by a top-tier Japanese firm eager to invest in U.S. manufacturing and benefit from America’s bipartisan infrastructure push. But what began as a potentially transformative industrial partnership immediately ran into political headwinds – not because it lacked promise, but because Joe Biden bowed to union pressures to earn their backing in a key swing state.
In January 2025, Biden blocked the deal outright on “national security” grounds, offering no clear path forward. His administration rejected Nippon’s $2.7 billion investment plan (a ten-figure commitment from a key ally), without demanding improvements or seeking leverage. That’s not strategy. That’s cowardice disguised as caution.
What happened next shows the difference real leadership can make.
When Donald Trump took office again in January, he didn’t simply rubber-stamp the deal. He did what a serious executive does: reopened the review and demanded better. According to Reuters, Trump’s team sought and obtained major upgrades to the investment package. The result? A tenfold increase in Nippon Steel’s pledge: from $1.4 billion last year to $14 billion today.
That number includes $4 billion for a brand-new steel mill, a facility that will create thousands of high-paying jobs, and $11 billion in upgrades to U.S. Steel’s infrastructure in the next three years. The greenfield site investment alone will rise from $1 billion to a projected $4 billion over time. This isn’t a marginal improvement. It’s a complete renegotiation — and it only happened because Donald Trump was in the room.
RELATED: Trump Speaks to Steelworkers at Celebration of Deal at US Steel Facility in Pittsburgh, PA
Could This Result in a Big, Beautiful Win in the Rust Belt?
Let’s be clear: Biden had the same deal on his desk and got nothing. Trump took the same proposal and transformed it into one of the most significant industrial commitments in modern American history.
Even now, the deal remains under review. But its current form – its scale, ambition, and national value – exists solely because Trump demanded more, and Nippon listened. The Japanese company is even keeping U.S. Steel’s headquarters in Pittsburgh and maintaining union contracts, delivering wins to both blue-collar workers and national security hawks.
This is a masterclass in economic statecraft. Trump didn’t reject foreign investment outright. He didn’t fall back on slogans. He recognized the strategic importance of steel, the reality of global supply chains, and the need to revitalize American manufacturing with precision — not politics.
Biden, by contrast, abandoned the field. His “national security” excuse satisfied no one. In fact, it triggered lawsuits from both U.S. Steel and Nippon Steel, who alleged that Biden’s review process was biased and unfair. If Biden had simply asked for more instead of saying no, America could have been months ahead on the path to steel revitalization.
Instead, the deal stalled until Trump took the wheel and drove it toward something great.
In the coming days, President Trump will decide whether this newly enhanced proposal gets the green light. But one thing is already certain: Only Trump had the strength to extract a better deal for America. Biden didn’t even try.
That’s the difference between rhetoric and results, between timidity and toughness. And it’s why Donald Trump remains the only leader fit to steward America’s industrial future.
Bianca Gracia is President of the Latinos for Trump/Latinos for America First Organization, Founder and Executive Director of Latinos for America First PAC. Gracia has appeared on Fox News, Steve Bannon’s War Room, NewsMax, OAN, and can be heard live Monday mornings at 8 am on 1440 Keys AM in Corpus Christi, Texas.
Editor's Note: President Trump is leading America into the "Golden Age" as Democrats try desperately to stop it.
Help us continue reporting on President Trump's success. Join RedState VIP and use promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your membership.