Summer House Season 9 has already introduced two new cast members to the Hamptons share house: Lexi Wood, a model with a rich dating history including Brooklyn Beckham and Presley Gerber, and Bailee Henderson, an influencer and nanny whose appearance in the series has sparked many questions among fans.

We first met Henderson, 27, in the Season 9 premiere when she showed up with her “bestie” and fellow newbie Wood, who lives “down the street” from her in the Big Apple. Not much else is known about Henderson, other than the fact that she’s from Lexington, Kentucky and she has some sort of situationship back in the city. Oh, and she previously met longtime star Amanda Batula through mutual friends. In her confessional, Batula described the newbie as “quirky” and “spunky,” noting that she “appreciates” her “awkwardness.”

While Henderson was very much so apart of the early days of Summer House Season 9, fans were quick to notice that she was excluded from the official cast photo as well as the Season 9 premiere party, prompting rumors to circulate.

One Bravo fan page (@BestOfBravo) claimed she was talking poorly about the cast and the show and leaking storylines when she’d go back to the city during the week until producers allegedly “confronted her and she stopped showing up,” per Reddit. Meanwhile, others wondered if she was cut from the show for being “too boring.”

However, it should be noted that stars Batula, Paige DeSorbo, and Ciara Miller are all still following her on Instagram. Henderson also posted a photo supporting Batula’s new swim line to her Instagram story earlier this week, writing, “Pop off sis YASSS.”

So, what actually happened that got Henderson booted from the Bravo series?

A source close to the situation told DECIDER, “She misrepresented some things in her life and it was a mutual decision to part ways.”

We’re not exactly sure how Henderson misrepresented herself, but fans are theorizing that she stopped filming somewhere around the third weekend. Whether her exit will be addressed in the show or she will disappear altogether remains to be seen.

Until then, you can still “send it” with Henderson and the rest of the Summer House gang when new episodes air every Wednesday at 9/8c on Bravo.