The Golden Bachelor Episode 4 gave Bachelor Nation a pickleball tournament, an adventurous one-on-one date, three emotional goodbyes, a glimpse at Gerry Turner’s tattoo, and perhaps most importantly, a spicy game of Never Have I Ever. But the fun isn’t over!
While Gerry and Leslie were off on their romantic date, the Golden Gals at the mansion played a hilarious game of Never Have I Ever with pints of ice cream. Viewers learned that April has kissed another woman’s husband, she and Sandra have each had sex in the workplace, everyone (except Kathy) has had sex in a car, and Susan has been with a woman sexually. The game was peak primetime TV, and if you’re one of many viewers who wanted to see more, you’re in luck!
Following Episode 4, The Golden Bachelor released a deleted scene that offers an extended look at the riveting game. In the 1:20-long clip, Sandra says “Never Have I Ever been skinny dipping — at the mansion” and Susan takes a bite of ice cream! Faith says, “Never Have I Ever been caught with any unmentionable toys at the airport” and Susan eats AGAIN! Kathy says, “Never Have I Ever spent more than $1,500” on a shopping spree and Susan (plus a few others) take a bite. Then, sweet little lactose-intolerant Sandra raises the stakes by saying, “Never Have I Ever sucked toes.” SANDRA, sweetie! What is this, Bachelor in Paradise?!
The room bursts into laughter, as comments like “what?!” and “ew!” fly. No one eats any ice cream, but April does chime in to say “Never— no wait, I did have my toes sucked!”
“Have you been the sucker or the suckee?!” Faith asks. “I’ve never sucked toes vs. I’ve never had my toes sucked.” LADIES!
As the game goes off the rails, Kathy simply lifts her bare foot to the camera, April makes a disgusted face, and Faith calls for an end to the toe-sucking talk. Unlike Paradise producers, the Golden Bachelor girls know when to quit.
“Never Have I Ever had sex when my parents were there,” Nancy says, starting the game back up. “I have,” April replies. “After church camp.”
As our eventually eliminated Golden Bachelor icon takes yet another bite of ice cream, her friends laugh along with her, and she says, “I’m sorry, mom.” That’s all this round! But here’s hoping the game becomes a Golden Bachelor tradition. And ABC, please keep releasing more unaired footage of this delightful series, because the good people of Bachelor Nation can’t get enough.
Tune in Thursday from 8:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. ET on ABC for another episode of The Golden Bachelor, or catch next-day streaming on Hulu. And be sure to read our interview with Gerry Turner for more Golden Bachelor tidbits.