When it comes to getting a good night’s sleep, the quality of your mattress plays a huge role. However, even the best mattresses can lose their edge over time, or maybe they just don’t offer the comfort or support you’re looking for. This is where a firm mattress topper comes into play.

A mattress topper is an additional layer of cushioning that sits on top of your mattress to help increase those ZZZs.

Mattress toppers also serve as a protective layer, helping to extend the life of your mattress by reducing wear and tear. “In many cases, this can give the mattress a couple of extra years before needing a complete replacement,” said John Merwin, CEO of 3Z Brands and Founder of Brooklyn Bedding. However, he admitted that this is not the case if your mattress is already “sagging” and that a topper will only “provide temporary relief rather than a lasting fix.”

If you’re a side sleeper, you’ll want a topper that cushions the curves of your body while still offering support. Back and stomach sleepers may need something a bit firmer to help keep their spine aligned through the night.

Now, throw a dog or a partner into the mix, and you’ll want something that absorbs movement, especially if your bedmate tends to flail like they’re fighting off nightmares. And if you sent your kid to college, have mercy on their youthful bodies because you know they’re sleeping on subpar mattresses. Just give them a shot at avoiding lower back pain until at least 40.

Truly, toppers are the cheapest way to improve your sleep without buying a new mattress.

How often should you replace your mattress topper? If you already own one but aren’t sure if it’s time for an upgrade, sleep expert Merwin recommends replacing it every three to five years. Over time, even the best toppers can lose their shape, trap heat, or stop providing the support you need for restful sleep.

If your topper feels flat, lumpy or you’re waking up sore more often than not, it’s probably past its prime. A new topper can refresh your entire sleep setup, adding pressure relief, softness, or temperature control where your mattress might be falling short. From cooling gel-infused foam to plush down alternatives and supportive latex, there are plenty of options that can make a noticeable difference in how you sleep and how you feel in the morning.

This will vary for everyone on what’s right for you. Choosing a material that fits your lifestyle makes all the difference. If you’re a hot sleeper, look for a gel-infused top to regulate your body temperature at night, but if breathable is your end game, you’ll want to find latex or wool.

Every material has its trade-offs. For example, a down topper feels like you’re sleeping in a soft, cozy nest but it tends to flatten over time. Memory foam is excellent for pressure relief, especially for your back or joints, but it can trap heat and might lead to night sweats.

The key is to figure out what comfort issue you’re trying to solve and match the material to that need.

There are many reasons why you should consider organic materials, from bamboo to organic cotton or latex. For those with sensitive skin or those looking to go the eco-friendly route, organic is a more sustainable and hypoallergenic choice.

“One of the most significant advantages is longevity,” said Merwin. “Organic latex, for example, is one of the most durable materials available and can perform better over time.” Because it is naturally sourced, you won’t get that overpowering chemical smell often found in brand-new mattresses or toppers fresh out of the box.

With so many styles and materials to choose from, finding the right mattress topper really comes down to your personal sleep style and comfort priorities. If you want to add a layer of cloud-like softness or firm up a too-squishy bed, a topper can transform your nights and mornings. 

The great news is that you don’t have to spend a fortune to feel the difference. Below, we’ve rounded up some of the best firm mattress toppers that offer serious comfort, reliable support, and just the right amount of upgrade for your sleep setup.

If you need advice on where to buy a mattress or what sheets to buy, you’re in luck; we researched everything you need to find the perfect night’s sleep. We even found the best mattress deals so you can save as much as possible. But also know that a topper can improve your sleep or reduce discomfort, especially if you suffer from chronic back pain or overheating.

Ready to find your perfect match?

Upgrade your sleep with the AirFoam Luxe Mattress Topper, which features an advanced high-density foam for superior support.

The foam contours to your body, offering exceptional comfort and pressure relief while minimizing motion transfer for a restful night.

Because you can choose from two height options and premium cover choices, including organic cotton or GlacioTex with cool-tech fibers, we vote this our favorite because it covers organic options and cradles your curves to help with side sleeping and severe pressure points.

Materials: AirFoam Luxe: CertiPUR-US certified polyurethane foam, Cover: GlacioTex (50/50 polyester and polyethylene) or organic cotton | Density: n/a, Thickness: n/a

For hot sleepers, Merwin recommended the GlacioTex, designed with cool-to-the-touch-
touch fabric to regulate the body’s temperature. It has a unique hybrid design with steel microcoils designed to cradle your body with more support while the memory foam relieves pressure.

We love that you can choose between a Luxury Plush Option with a softer feel or a Luxury Firm Option if you need more firmness for your back. It’s a great choice if your mattress is starting to sag or is too soft already.

The Helix mattress topper is made in a U.S. facility, with free shipping and a 100-night trial. You can’t go wrong. Available in Twin to California King.

Material: 50/50 blend of polyester and polyethylene | Density: 1.5-inch High-Density Foam | Thickness: 3.75-inches tall

This mattress topper is Merwin’s top pick for those with sensitive skin or for anyone in need of a hypoallergenic option. Made from sustainably sourced natural rubber latex from South American rubber trees, it features 100% Talalay latex and is covered in organic fabric. It comes in three firmness levels: soft, medium, and firm, each encased in 100% cotton.

“It’s a solid choice for eco-conscious shoppers,” said Merwin.

Additionally, if you live in a walk-up apartment or a tight space, it comes in a compact, roll-packed box for easy delivery and setup.

Material: 100% latex with a 100% cotton covering | Density: soft, medium and firm options | Thickness: 3 inches in depth

New York Post Review: “I’m not proud to admit this, but I spent the last year sleeping on a used mattress. Not shocking — It was stiff as a rock, and I didn’t want to get anywhere close to it. The simple solution was to add a mattress pad, and this piece from Sleep Number was the answer to my prayers. Smooth, plush, and just the right amount of bouncy — the blend of memory foam and lyocell is probably the only thing keeping my back pain at bay.

The grippy corner bands keep it snuggly in place. It never slips around and is far less of an eyesore than some other lumpier pads I’ve seen tucked under sheets. Yes, you can probably find an okay mattress that’s cheaper than it, but I still think it’s a great investment considering it’s easy to spot-clean and will last as long as you take good care of it. In fact, I’ve since upgraded to a nice mattress, but I am so attached to it that I’m still sleeping on it.” – Miska Salemann, commerce writer

Material: Outer cover top: 31% lyocell, 68% polyester, 1% spandex. Outer bottom cover: 100% polyester | Density: n/a | Thickness: n/a

When it comes to improving your sleep quality, a mattress topper can make a huge difference. It offers an affordable way to add comfort and support to your existing mattress. However, with so many options available, it can be challenging to choose the best one. Here’s a guide to help you make an informed decision based on key factors like material, thickness and density, sleep trial, price, and warranty.

A mattress pad vs topper is often confused as the same thing so for the purpose of this article we’re referring to these as mattress toppers but a mattress pad is designed to keep liquids and other substances from seeping into your bed as well as improve the comfort whereas a a mattress topper is designed to offer relief to your bod while sleeping and to prolong the life of your mattress, according to the Sleep Foundation.

The material of a mattress topper plays a crucial role in the comfort and support it provides. Common options include:

The thickness and density of a mattress topper impact how much support and cushioning you’ll get.

Mattress toppers typically range from 2 to 4 inches in thickness. A thicker topper (3-4 inches) is ideal if you need significant cushioning or want to change the feel of a firmer mattress. A thinner topper (2 inches) provides a more subtle change and is suitable for people who just want to add a bit of softness without altering the mattress too much.

The density of the material affects the firmness and durability of the topper. Higher-density foams tend to be firmer, while lower-density foams provide a softer feel.

A sleep trial is a period during which you can test out the mattress topper and return it if it doesn’t meet your expectations. It’s essential to choose a topper that offers a sleep trial because you need time to adjust to the topper and assess how it affects your sleep.

The feel of a mattress topper can differ after a few nights of use, especially with materials like memory foam, which can take time to fully expand and adjust to your body.

Look for a sleep trial of at least 30 nights (many brands offer 60-100 night trials), giving you enough time to determine if the topper is the right fit.

Mattress toppers are generally more affordable than buying a new mattress, but the price can vary greatly depending on the material and brand. Expect to pay anywhere from $50 to $500, with memory foam and latex toppers falling in the higher price range. Luxury materials like organic latex, gel-infused memory foam, and down alternatives tend to be on the higher side but the benefits may be worth it depending on what you need.

A warranty makes it so your topper is protected against defects and premature wear. Most toppers come with a 3-10-year warranty, depending on the material and brand. Memory foam toppers often come with longer warranties, while down or feather toppers typically have shorter warranties.

Choosing the right mattress topper depends on your specific needs, whether you want extra softness, firmness, support, or cooling.

When shopping for a mattress topper, there are several reputable brands to consider, each offering unique benefits. Dormeo is known for its innovative memory foam and Octaspring technology, providing exceptional pressure relief and comfort. Purple stands out with its Hyper-Elastic Polymer grid, designed for a cool, supportive sleeping surface. Tempur-Pedic offers high-density memory foam toppers that excel in motion isolation and pressure relief, while Serta provides affordable, high-quality options with their renowned memory foam and pillowtop choices. Walmart and Target both offer budget-friendly selections from popular brands like Mainstays and Linenspa, giving shoppers an accessible option without sacrificing comfort.

For premium options, Saatva offers eco-friendly, luxurious memory foam toppers that enhance spinal alignment, while Avocado uses organic materials to provide a natural sleep experience. Casper is known for its breathable foam and thoughtful design that helps keep sleepers cool, and Lucid provides a variety of memory foam and gel-infused toppers at a competitive price point. MyPillow’s toppers are designed for customizable comfort with adjustable fill, and Allswell offers a balanced hybrid model with cooling features. Costco and Amazon provide a range of brands and topper types, allowing you to find a product that fits your specific needs, while IKEA’s affordable foam and latex options offer a solid foundation for restful sleep. Other types of toppers to consider are bamboo mattress toppers for cooling or down mattress toppers and feather mattress toppers for soft, breathable comfort.

If you’re looking for high-end luxury, eco-friendly choices, or budget-friendly options, there’s a topper for every sleeper.

For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.