THE AMERICA ONE NEWS
May 31, 2025  |  
0
 | Remer,MN
Sponsor:  QWIKET 
Sponsor:  QWIKET 
Sponsor:  QWIKET: Elevate your fantasy game! Interactive Sports Knowledge.
Sponsor:  QWIKET: Elevate your fantasy game! Interactive Sports Knowledge and Reasoning Support for Fantasy Sports and Betting Enthusiasts.
back  
topic
NY Post
New York Post
22 Feb 2023


NextImg:Bodega clerk Jose Alba plans to sue NYC over wrongful prosecution in murder case

The bodega worker who was infamously charged with murder after stabbing an assailant inside the store will sue the city for wrongfully prosecuting him and for the time he was jailed in Rikers Island before his case was finally dropped, The Post has learned.

Jose Alba, 61, plans to file suit next month, his attorney, Imran Ansari, said Wednesday.

Alba in September filed notices of claim against the city and the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office for $10 million, alleging they wrongfully brought a case against him for fatally stabbing ex-con Austin Simon, 35, in self-defense on July 1, 2022.

Advertisement

The notices – the legal precursors to lawsuits against certain New York agencies – claim the NYPD botched the investigation and withheld critical evidence from the DA’s office that would have cleared Alba’s name.

Alba – who was stabbed by Simon’s girlfriend in the incident – also filed a notice of claim against the city Health and Hospitals Corporation claiming that during his time in jail at Rikers he wasn’t given proper medical treatment for his stab wounds, one of which became infected.

The hardworking clerk spent six nights at the troubled lockup before prosecutors in District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office agreed to lower his $250,000 bail. The second-degree murder charges were dropped by the DA on July 19 amid growing pressure and outrage from the public over his innocence.

Jose Alba plans to sue the city for wrongful arrest in the death of Austin Simon.
Alec Tabak

Advertisement

Alba claims from start to finish his case was mishandled, beginning when cops arrived at the scene in Hamilton Heights and failed to take witness statements including from himself, the filing alleges.

Instead, the police “relied solely on the incredible word” of Simon’s girlfriend – Tina Lee – who stabbed Alba in the melee, the claim papers state. Lee had beckoned Simon inside the Blue Moon Convenience store because she was angry her EBT debit card wouldn’t go through for a bag of chips for her 10-year-old daughter.

1 of 5
Jose Alba stabbing Austin Simon
Simon came behind the counter with Alba was working and Alba stabbed him in self-defense.
Jose Alba stabbing Austin Simon.
Simon died from the stab wounds.
Advertisement
Jose Alba defending himself from Austin Simon.
During the melee Simon’s girlfriend stabbed Alba.
Advertisement

Cops also neglected to look at video of the incident “which was available, and which clearly showed there was no criminal liability on the part of Alba,” the filling alleges.

Advertisement

And instead of taking Alba straight to the hospital to get treated for his stab wound “despite his requests,” officers brought him to the 30th precinct to interrogate him, the claim papers state.

The police then “failed to present all relevant and exculpatory information to the NY County District Attorney’s Office and withheld exculpatory information,” the claim states.

Protesters holding "Free Alba" sign.

The case was dropped against Alba a few weeks later after mounting public pressure decrying his innocence.
Gregory P. Mango

The DA’s office, based on the information from cops, brought “the highest charge possible” against Alba and asked for extremely high bail “so that Alba would be punished regardless of the facts of the case,” the filing states. Prosecutors also “decided not to arrest Tina Lee who had no reasonable basis to stab Alba,” the claim says.

Advertisement

Bragg, in a public statement at the time of the arrest, admitted that his office was still reviewing evidence and the investigation was ongoing. But “This review … should have been done by the NYPD and DA investigators before Alba was arrested and charged,” the filing states.

At Rikers, Alba was kept “under inhumane and unconstitutional conditions,” the claim states. He was kept in the intake area without COVID-19 protections and only hours after his arrival was he finally taken to the medical facility where they said he’d need to have his wound cleaned twice daily and pain and fever medications administered to help prevent infection, the papers claim.

Jose Alba's scars.

Alba claims law enforcement didn’t offer him prompt medical treatment for his stab wounds.

Yet correction officers and jail staff didn’t answer his “numerous requests” for treatment and “one of the wounds became infected,” the claim states.

In the DA’s court papers finally seeking to drop the case against him “it was apparent that all of the evidence the DA reviewed was available at the time Alba was arrested and before Alba was charged,” the filing alleges.

Jose Alba.

Alba also says he wasn’t offered proper medical treatment at Rikers Island and one wound became infected.
Alec Tabak

“The motion states that Simon was the aggressor but the explanation for not arresting Lee for stabbing Alba made no sense, as Lee had stabbed Alba as he was lawfully defending himself,” the claim papers say.

Alba plans to sue for claims including false arrest, malicious prosecution, withholding exculpatory information and unconstitutional conditions of confinement.

Advertisement

“Jose Alba is a hardworking New Yorker who was confronted with a choice, defend himself from a violent attack, or face possible dire consequences,” Alba’s lawyers, Ansari and Richard Cardinale, said in a statement.

“Unfortunately, law enforcement didn’t see it that way, and put an innocent man through the system, forced him to endure harsh conditions on Rikers Island, and failed to provide him adequate medical treatment, before dismissing his charges in the face of mounting pressure and public outrage,” the statement continued.

The NYPD said it “will decline to comment on pending litigation.”

Advertisement

The city Law Department, the DA’s office and the city Health and Hospitals Corporation all didn’t return requests for comment Wednesday.

Additional reporting by Craig McCarthy and Elizabeth Rosner