Vincent Geloso of the Montreal Economic Institute committed heresy in a report released Wednesday: If we believe all tariffs are bad, as we say we do then, he argued, we should be “removing all import taxes and other barriers to foreign producers and investors, without any expectation of reciprocity.”

Don’t drop tariffs and non-tariff trade barriers as part of a deal with the White House, in other words. Just drop them, and let companies and consumers enjoy lower input prices.