Catherine O’Hara is being lined up for a starring role on Only Murders in the Building. The hit TV show has previously featured the likes of Cara Delevingne, Paul Rudd and Meryl Streep. John Hoffman — the show’s co-creator — has now revealed that he would love to work with O’Hara.

Asked who’s left on his casting bucket list, Hoffman told The Hollywood Reporter: “There are so many. But I’ll be honest: we’ve inquired, because I love her so much, about Catherine O’Hara.”