They say the early bird gets the worm, but according to Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco, that’s not always a great thing.

While appearing on “Spotify’s Countdown To…” on Wednesday, the couple opened up about a “mortifying” experience they faced at one of Taylor Swift’s parties in the early stage of their relationship.

“What was our first party that we ever went to?” Blanco, 37, asked Gomez, 32, in a clip, prompting the singer to launch into a hilarious tidbit about them being overly punctual to the pop star’s shindig.

“I don’t know if this was the first but it was actually really funny. As a couple we went to Taylor’s party after some awards show,” Gomez recalled. “I don’t know, it was kind of cute, but I was mortified. Apparently cool people don’t show up to parties on time.”

Blanco then teased his fiancée by comparing Gomez’s knack for arriving early to his mom.

“We’re the first people at every single party when I go with you. You show up when, like, my mother shows up to a party,” the record producer joked, before revealing what he thought her answer would be.

Blanco added, “I thought you were gonna talk about the fact that no one knew we were dating and we were hiding the fact that we were dating.”

Gomez and Blanco announced their engagement back in December. Swift, a longtime friend of Gomez, had an adorable reaction to the pair’s big news.

After the “Emilia Pérez” star and Blanco posted about their nuptials on Instagram, Swift jumped into the comments section, writing, “Yes I will be the flower girl.”

Watch Gomez and Blanco’s appearance on “Spotify’s Countdown To…” below.