The policy was proposed after the gay pride flag was flown outside city hall last year, sparking fierce debate among residents.
The gay pride flag was flown outside Green Bay's city hall last year. (Getty Images)
Genrich openly opposed the proposed flag policy and reportedly threatened the council that he would veto it if it was adopted, NBC26 reported.
He argued that limiting the flags to the American, city and POW flags outside government buildings "represents really a retrograde, backward-looking view of our community," adding,"I just don't have any time or tolerance for it."
GOP BILL SAYS ONLY THE AMERICAN FLAG CAN FLY OVER US EMBASSIES: NO MORE PRIDE, BLM FLAGS
Alderman Chris Wery, who proposed the policy, said that he did so to ensure residents were equally represented outside government buildings.
People vote at the Milwaukee County Sports Complex on Nov. 3, 2020, in Franklin, Wisconsin. (AP Photo/Morry Gash, File)
"What's more fair and equal than playing no favorites?" Wery said, according to NBC26. "What is more fair and equal, playing no favorites with our flagpole? That's equality for all right there."
Members of the LGBTQ+ community who joined the meeting called the proposal "fundamentally inhumane and immoral."
"We need our flag to fly as an indication that we are safe and valued members of this community," one resident said.
Green Bay Mayor Eric Henrich.
Genrich's office did not immediately respond to Fox News's request for comment.
The debate surrounding which flags to fly outside city buildings is not exclusive to the Badger State. This week, a California beach community voted to reverse its decision to fly the gay pride flag in front of government buildings two years after the city council unanimously voted in favor of the move. The Huntington Beach community will now only permit a select group of flags to be flown outside government buildings.