South Park just hurled another cartoon brick at the Trump administration. Predictably, the internet roared its approval. Social feeds lit up with praise for Trey Parker and Matt Stone’s latest “savage takedown.” Blue-check pundits called it brave. Reddit called it brutal. Headlines wrote themselves.
However, once you strip away the animated vulgarity, an unspoken truth sits there in plain view: South Park is no longer funny.
Good satire doesn’t just sneer at its target; it dissects it, exposes the gears, and shows the absurdity in a way that forces even the target’s supporters to smirk in reluctant recognition.
This isn’t about defending Trump. I’ve never hesitated to call him out when it was deserved. My problem is with the comedy itself. Good satire doesn’t just sneer at its target; it dissects it, exposes the gears, and shows the absurdity in a way that forces even the target’s supporters to smirk in reluctant recognition. It’s a mirror, not a megaphone. It sharpens thought rather than flattering prejudice. It can punch in any direction because the joke is anchored in truth, not tribal applause. That’s where South Park fails. It isn’t holding up a mirror anymore; it’s holding up a cue card for the audience to read back to itself.
Season 27 drones on like a broken alarm clock. What was once television’s most fearless satirical voice now plays like a weekly gripe session with punchlines stapled on. The scalpel that used to carve through sacred cows has been swapped for a wooden spoon. Crude humor once wrapped something sharper inside it. Now, it’s the whole meal. Every episode this season reduces Trump — and anyone within shouting distance of him — to a parade of genitals and bathroom gags, a string of urinal-wall doodles passed off as satire. I laughed at that stuff when I was thirteen. Then I grew up. Parker and Stone, decades older, are still loitering by the lockers, peddling the same joke like it’s contraband.
That’s not an outsider’s sneer. I’ve been in their corner most of my life. I know how good they can be, which is exactly why the slide is so glaring. South Park hasn’t just lost its edge; it’s started carving itself into a caricature. It has slipped into self-parody. (RELATED: The Estonian ‘Killer’)
There was a time when the crudity carried a cutting edge. When South Park went after public figures — Kanye West, Mel Gibson, Caitlyn Jenner — it didn’t just lob easy insults. It built something of real substance. The humor was filthy, but the framing was razor-sharp. They didn’t just point and yell “ridiculous” — they built a case. Mel Gibson wasn’t tossed off as another celebrity meltdown; he became a study in how guilt and grievance can harden into zealotry. Kanye West wasn’t just an ego in designer shades; he was a walking satire of celebrity narcissism and the industry that enables it. Meanwhile, Caitlyn Jenner was used to explore the uneasy collision of personal identity, media idolatry, and political convenience.
The laughs landed, but they carried weight. You laughed, then you thought about why. There was escalation, structure, and sting. The satire came from inside the culture, not lobbed from the cheap seats.
Now, however, the writing is brittle, the edge blunted. Somewhere in the Trump years, South Park learned that outrage sells faster than insight. The media bites, social platforms boost, and viewers mistake ridicule for bravery. A poop joke becomes a political act. Why wrestle with allegory when you can scrawl anatomy and trend?
The decline was gradual — flimsy seasons, lazy parodies — until the full pivot to chasing headlines. Every episode became welded to the week’s discourse: TikTok fads, COVID hysteria, election gossip, social media feuds. The depth evaporated. The kids stopped being kids and became avatars for the trending topic. South Park once set the cultural tone; now it refreshes the feed. (RELATED: Cancelling the Late Late Show)
Episodes now play like 22-minute tweets — loud, shallow, and gone before the credits finish rolling. Parker and Stone aren’t fools. They built their careers on precision and nerve, and they can see the well has run dry. That’s why it stings more. They should know when to stop. They could walk away and leave South Park as a show that defined a generation. Instead, they’ve settled for a long, undignified victory lap. Each new season is a weekend-at-Bernie’s performance, hauling the body around for one more cheer, one more trending clip, one more reminder of what it used to be.
Politics didn’t break South Park. They’ve always done politics — and at their peak, did it brilliantly. Now the humor feeds the same apathy it once skewered. It reacts instead of anticipates, scrapes instead of sharpens.
This season set out to ridicule Trump and his orbit. In the process, it exposed something larger: a show once armed with cultural shrapnel now firing blanks, coasting on the ghost of its former glory.
READ MORE from John Mac Ghlionn:
What’s Happening in Minnesota Should Alarm All Americans