Last year, I wrote an op-ed arguing that Taylor Swift was not a good role model for young women. It was not a popular opinion. I said she had built a career on railing against the so-called patriarchy while simultaneously dating the very men who defined it — wealthy, powerful, influential white males. She fed on the feminist fantasy of being a man-eater, the woman who conquered the conquerors. Each breakup became creative fuel. Each heartbreak, a headline. Her life was her marketing plan, and her lovers were her muses. (RELATED: Taylor Swift a Self-Made Billionaire?)
Now that she’s engaged to Travis Kelce, that playbook is finished. The ammunition is gone. The feminist avenger has traded her sword for a saucepan. And while that may bring her personal happiness, it will almost certainly blunt her professional edge. (RELATED: Will Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Single-Handedly Save Marriage?)
Swift’s career was built on contradiction. She sold rebellion while craving approval, painted herself as an outsider while being the most inside of insiders. She performed victimhood with precision, inviting sympathy and envy in equal measure. The music was personal, yes, but also perfectly packaged revenge — heartbreak as entertainment, confession as commerce. Every failed romance wasn’t an end; it was material. The tabloids became her tour bus. The men she dated — from Jake Gyllenhaal to Joe Alwyn — were raw inspiration for the next era.
But marriage is a full stop in that sentence. Domestic bliss doesn’t chart. It doesn’t trend. There’s no bite in ballads about contentment. Her new album, The Life of a Showgirl, is proof. The hooks are half-hearted, the writing flat. Gone is the electric sting of songs like “All Too Well” or “Blank Space.” In their place: soft rock lullabies about comfort and suburban calm. Critics are already calling it dull — and they’re right. Swift without heartbreak is a storyteller without conflict.
They no longer need a pop priestess of perpetual pain.
There’s also a cultural shift unfolding. Swift rose during an age that celebrated grievance. Her brand of feminism was built on being wronged — by men, by media, by the music business. She became the face of a generation that found empowerment through victimhood. But in her mid-30s, that act has worn thin. The world has changed, and so has she. The young women who once sang along to “Shake It Off” are now mothers, wives, or simply tired of being told that anger is a virtue. They no longer need a pop priestess of perpetual pain. (RELATED: Why Is Every Brand Suddenly Acting Like a Taylor Swift Superfan?)
And young men? They’ve long since checked out. Swift’s public disdain for “toxic masculinity” was always paired with her private preference for its beneficiaries. The message was muddled: condemn the patriarchy, date its princes. Even her engagement — to a multimillionaire NFL star — fits the pattern. It isn’t rebellion. It’s regression wrapped in romance. (RELATED: Travis Kelce Is the Blueprint Democrats Have Been Missing)
Her defenders will insist she’s evolving, that it’s possible to mature without losing one’s magic. Maybe. But pop is a cruel mirror. It rewards youth, chaos, and self-creation. Swift has exhausted all three. The Eras Tour was her coronation — a greatest-hits victory lap before the inevitable fade. No one can sustain the myth at that scale forever. Once you’ve written yourself into legend, there’s nowhere left to go but ordinary.
Swift built an empire on the illusion of authenticity — diary entries dressed as anthems, confessions calibrated for maximum reach. But domestic life is not the stage. It doesn’t feed the same beast. The feminist firebrand who once vowed never to be tamed is now flirting with tameness. She’ll try to turn that into art, of course — she always does — but the spark that once came from restlessness can’t be faked.
There’s a reason the greats burn bright and early. They channel chaos, heartbreak, and hunger into something sublime. But once peace arrives, so does predictability. And predictability is death in pop music. Madonna learned it. Adele mellowed into it. Katy Perry drowned in it. Beyoncé dodged it by sheer reinvention. Swift, however, has built a universe too centered on herself to allow real transformation. She is the brand. And the brand, now, is boring.
This isn’t cruelty, but reality. Swift’s story has reached its natural conclusion. The girl who wanted love found it. The woman who sought power got it. But for an artist who thrived on longing, contentment is creative quicksand.
In the end, Taylor Swift will not go out with a bang but a hum — the soft sound of a superstar settling down. The world will still watch, still cheer, still sing along. But the spell is broken. The era of the man-eater is over. And in its place stands something smaller, safer, and far less interesting: a woman who finally has everything, and therefore nothing left to say.
READ MORE from John Mac Ghlionn:
Christianity at the Crossroads