Culture is more than galleries and symphonies. It’s not just what hangs on a wall or flickers on a stage — it’s what pulses through the streets. How people live. How they treat each other. What they tolerate, and what they won’t. Culture is everything from high art to street-level ethics. From cathedrals to crime scenes.
That’s why the word itself is so slippery. You can interpret it a hundred ways. A canvas. A riot. A prayer. A protest. Paris is a masterclass in that ambiguity.
Time Out just crowned it the “world’s best city for culture.” They polled 18,500 residents, tallied votes from experts, name-dropped the Louvre, and threw around phrases like “euphoric energy” and “weightless performances.” It’s all very poetic. Very curated. Very Paris.
But it’s also deeply incomplete — sanitized, even — a glossy brochure version of a city many Parisians no longer recognize. Because culture may start in museum corridors, but it spills into the streets. And in Paris, those streets are cracked open by riots, littered with broken glass, and haunted by the hum of sirens after dark. Try wandering to your next exhibition while dodging a knife attack on the Métro. Try sipping an espresso while youths set cars ablaze three blocks over. Or watching on as police officers are gunned down in broad daylight.
Paris is a melting pot. But what it’s melting into isn’t all wine and ballet.
It’s Molotov cocktails and stolen scooters. It’s pickpocket rings and police in body armor. It’s a metropolis where tourists photograph gothic cathedrals while someone gets sexually assaulted in a public park down the road.
The old and the sacred collide daily with the new and the lawless. Cathedrals next to crack dens. Luxury fashion boutiques adjacent to makeshift migrant camps. It’s not just contrast — it’s collapse dressed in Dior.
Yes, Paris has always had an unmistakable edge. But there’s a clear difference between bohemian messiness and existential breakdown. What we’re seeing now is something else, something more volatile.
Go ahead — visit the Louvre. Take in the Musée d’Orsay. Wander the galleries. But just know: if you walk a few blocks too far in the wrong direction, you’ll hit a very different kind of exhibit. Open-air drug markets. Groups of men harassing women in broad daylight. And it’s not just the outer suburbs anymore. It’s central. It’s creeping inward. I say this as someone who has visited the city many times and was just there a few months ago.
Sure, the Eiffel Tower still sparkles. Paris can still be beautiful. No one’s denying that the Louvre is still packed.
But so are the courtrooms. So are the ERs.
We talk about culture like it’s fragile. A thing to be protected. But what if it’s already broken? What if the museums and monuments are now just decorative masks for something much darker underneath?
Ask the locals — not the ones working PR. Ask the café owner who’s been robbed three times this year. Ask the elderly woman who won’t ride the subway anymore. Ask the mother who sends her daughter to school with a pepper spray canister clipped to her backpack.
This isn’t a hit piece. It’s a reality check.
The truth is, Paris is now two cities: one for the travel writers and Instagram influencers and one for everyone else — the under-policed, the under-protected, and the quietly terrified.
We are told to celebrate diversity, romanticize chaos, and call everything “vibrant.” However, what’s happening in Paris isn’t vibrancy. It’s violence.
It’s not multiculturalism. Not the good kind, anyway. It’s unmanaged collapse. And yes, culture can be interpreted differently. But if your cultural capital looks more like a war zone than a wonderland, maybe it’s time to stop handing out awards and ask some harder questions.
This isn’t just Paris. The same symptoms are showing up across Europe. London, once the pride of the Commonwealth, now wrestles with gang stabbings, acid attacks, and cultural fragmentation. Dublin staggers under housing shortages, rising street crime, and an uneasy tension in its once-cozy neighborhoods. Berlin, Stockholm, Brussels — name a capital, and you’ll find the same patterns: assimilation abandoned, identity diluted, disorder tolerated in the name of virtue.
And still, the ruling class offers hashtags and silly slogans. “Unity in diversity” sounds lovely until you’re told to ignore the sirens, the riots, the no-go zones, the communities being ripped apart. At some point, a nation must ask: how much reality are we willing to sacrifice to protect a narrative? Because if the cost of progress is pretending not to see decay, then maybe we’ve already failed.
READ MORE from John Mac Ghlionn:
The Band That Hates America Would Be Nothing Without America