I remember a time when neighborhoods sounded remarkably human. Infants wailed and toddlers shrieked. Parents, bleary-eyed and jittery with caffeine, barked orders like half-deranged lieutenants trying to hold the line. Arms flapped, milk spilled, and cereal launched across kitchens like shrapnel. It was chaotic, yes — but it was life.
It means we’ve stumbled into a kind of post-familial fog — a secular monasticism dressed in sweatpants and matted with dog hair.
Today, however, the soundtrack is fading, and fast. In cities from Tokyo to Toronto, the noise has changed. Now it’s a different kind of barking — the soft jingle of collar bells, and grown adults crooning “Who’s my darling?” to a creature with four legs, a wet nose, and zero chance of ever giving them grandchildren.
Welcome to the era of dog-as-child, the cuddly endpoint of a demographic decline so severe it might warrant a trigger warning. In nation after nation — Germany, South Korea, Italy, Japan, even the U.S. — fertility rates are plummeting while the pet industry booms. Millennials and Zoomers have discovered a curious workaround to the terrifying trifecta of diapers, debt, and domestic drudgery: don’t have kids. Buy a dog. Dress it like a toddler. Whisper sweet nothings into its floppy ears while sipping overpriced lattes and posting paw-dicures (pedicures for pets) on Instagram.
It’s cute. It’s tragic. And it’s spreading like kennel cough in a rescue center.
To be fair, dogs have always held a special place in the human heart. They’ve guarded us, herded for us, hunted with us, and died at our sides. But never before have they been mistaken — earnestly, insistently — for our literal children. The rise of the “fur baby” isn’t just a cultural quirk. It’s an evolutionary bait-and-switch, a psychological shell game that rewires primal instincts and redirects them toward something easier, softer, and ultimately sterile. (RELATED: The People Who Came for Your Plastic Bag and Straw Now Want Your Dog)
This isn’t parenting-lite. This is parenting cosplay.
One recent study found that 37 percent of dog owners identify as “pet parents.” In America and beyond, some dogs now have more elaborate birthday parties than most humans. These aren’t the mutts of yesteryear, raised outdoors, taught to behave, occasionally fed table scraps. These are pampered, stroller-bound companions wearing matching family Christmas pajamas, complete with their own social media accounts and treat-based reward charts.
There’s even a booming market for doggy fertility clinics. No, seriously. While human birth rates plummet and governments beg women to have just one child, people are forking over thousands to help golden retrievers ovulate on schedule. We won’t fund daycare, but we’ll bankroll canine IVF. If that’s not the final punchline of a dying civilization, it’s at least the setup. (RELATED: We Told People Not to Have Kids — Now We’re Surprised They Listened)
One has to wonder: Did humans become so efficient at avoiding hardship that we engineered ourselves out of existence? It’s a fair question to ask. Make no mistake, dogs are easier. They don’t need braces. They don’t ask about the meaning of life. They don’t grow into angsty teens who hate you for chewing too loudly. They won’t go to college. A dog’s loyalty is unflinching, their dependency flattering, and their death conveniently timed — 12 to 15 years, give or take, leaving just enough emotional runway for the next “child.”
It’s surrogacy as lifestyle branding. A cycle dressed up as devotion: love, lose, replace. Grieve, adopt, repeat. What was once a biological imperative — raising actual children with minds of their own — has been quietly outsourced to creatures that can’t speak, won’t vote, and will never challenge your politics, your priorities, or your delusions. It’s comfort without consequence.
A Dog-Dominated Future?
Which begs another question: What does this mean for the future of humanity?
It means we’ve stumbled into a kind of post-familial fog — a secular monasticism dressed in sweatpants and matted with dog hair. The nuclear family is being replaced by the solo adult, curled up under three weighted blankets, spooning a rescue mutt with separation anxiety and severe gluten intolerance.
And for millions — especially women — the message is clear: those ancient, biological instincts to protect, nurture, and raise the next generation? Channel them into a French bulldog with a collapsing trachea and a wardrobe more expensive than most toddlers. Forget the cradle. Embrace the crate.
Is it empowering? In a carefully marketed, serotonin-on-a-leash kind of way, maybe. Is it dystopian? Absolutely. The apocalypse won’t be televised. It’ll be livestreamed on Instagram, filtered through soft light, and captioned, “My baby.”
We’ve survived plagues, wars, famines, and tyrants. And yet, the soft suffocation of comfort, loneliness, and postmodern individualism may be what finally wipes us out. I’m certainly not saying dogs are bad. They’re loyal, loving, and often more tolerable than most humans. But when entire societies start trading bassinets for BarkBoxes, we should be alarmed. It’s a symptom — of atomization, cultural fatigue, of a species slowly forgetting its purpose.
We may yet rebuild. We may yet crawl out of this sterile comfort and remember what it means to raise something that outlives us. Something unruly, defiant, human. We may rediscover the beauty in legacy — the kind that cries at 3 a.m. and slams doors at 13. The kind that breaks your heart not because it dies, but because it grows up, moves out, and keeps going — without you. But that kind of love requires courage, and courage is a currency in short supply.
READ MORE from John Mac Ghlionn: