In the United States, out-of-wedlock birth rates have increased across racial groups in recent decades. According to the CDC (see page 25), approximately 70% of Black children, 53% of Hispanic children, and 30% of White children are born to unmarried mothers. These statistics are often linked to discussions about youth crime and illiteracy due to observed correlations. However, correlation does not imply causation, as these outcomes stem from complex, multifaceted socioeconomic factors. Single-parent households, more prevalent in minority communities, are associated with challenges like economic strain, reduced supervision, and weaker social networks, which can elevate the risk of youth crime. For instance: the National Academies Press highlights that youth in high-risk neighborhoods, often marked by poverty and single-parent homes, face higher rates of serious criminal activity.
The America First Policy Institute notes that children from single-parent households are more likely to experience psychosocial issues, truancy, school violence, substance abuse, and involvement in the juvenile justice system.
A 2017 study found that children of incarcerated parents are more likely to run afoul of law enforcement, thus perpetuating cycles of crime.
However, broader factors like poverty and inadequate education significantly influence crime rates, complicating the role of family structure. Illiteracy among youth is similarly tied to family dynamics but heavily mediated by socioeconomic conditions. Single-parent households, particularly those in poverty, often lack the resources to foster literacy due to financial or time constraints. A 2010 report indicates that 85% of youth in the juvenile justice system are functionally illiterate, as are 60% of incarcerated adults. Literacy programs reduce recidivism rates to 16%, compared to 70% for those without literacy support.
Intergenerational illiteracy exacerbates challenges, with parents in low-income or single-parent settings often lacking the skills to promote reading. Over 70% of children with undereducated parents live in low-income environments. Systemic issues, such as underperforming public schools in minority neighborhoods, further hinder literacy development.
Poverty, not just family structure, drives illiteracy. Over 50% of impoverished households lack children’s books, and minority communities face higher poverty rates -- 17% for Black and Hispanic Americans compared to 7% for Whites in 2024.
This need not be the case. There are numerous examples of people who have overcome disadvantaged childhoods and gone on to achieve great success, not only in athletics but also in the fields of academics, business, and the judiciary. For example, Oprah Winfrey, Dr. Ben Carson, Sonia Sotomayor, Clarence Thomas, Selena Gomez and Charles Payne were raised in single-parent, low-income homes and overcame those difficulties to achieve great success. Dr. Carson’s story is especially poignant and I encourage the reader to follow that link.
Historical data shows that Black poverty rates dropped significantly between 1940 and 1960. However, following Great Society interventions, black labor force participation declined, unemployment rose, and the black nuclear family structure weakened. Black male homicide rates, which fell in the 1940s and 1950s, surged over the next three decades, highlighting broader societal shifts.
While some attribute crime and illiteracy directly to illegitimacy, this oversimplifies the issue. Structural inequalities, such as failing schools and persistent poverty, play significant roles. To address youth crime and illiteracy, comprehensive strategies must target root causes like poverty, educational disparities, and limited parental resources, rather than focusing solely on family structure.
Effective interventions include:
By implementing these strategies, communities can foster literacy and reduce crime among youth, particularly in minority populations facing socioeconomic challenges, creating a stronger foundation for success.
Image: Pexels/Marta Wave